CIMAS Not Shutting Down, Wins Licence Case

CIMAS Not Shutting Down, Wins Licence Case
Published: 2016 May 17 02:06:01 (1694 Views)
The High Court has barred Government from cancelling CIMAS Medical Aid Society’s operating licence pending finalisation of its dispute with Corporate 24 Group of Hospitals.

Justice November Mtshiya set aside the decision by Deputy Minister of Health and Child Care Dr Aldrin Musiiwa to cancel CIMAS’ licence.

The threat of CIMAS, one of the largest medical aid societies in the country, losing its licence had caused panic and chaos among the membership but the court set the decision aside.

The two companies entered an agreement whereby CIMAS members would be treated at Corporate 24 Hospital using their valid medical aid cards and CIMAS would later pay for the services directly to the hospital.

CIMAS accused Corporate 24 of processing fraudulent medical aid claims and exaggerating the figures, a development that temporarily ended the direct payment system between the two firms.

It is claimed CIMAS reported to Government its discovery of fraudulent claims, but little action was taken by the Ministry of Health and Child Care.

Corporate 24 then made its report complaining of the unpaid bills and the termination of the direct payment system and the ministry arranged meetings with the two parties.

CIMAS wants a forensic audit of the claims first before honouring the debt.

Dr Musiiwa wrote to CIMAS giving it seven days ultimatum to comply with Government’s directive or risk losing its licence.

CIMAS through its lawyers Mr Raymond Moyo of Gill Godlonton and Gerrans and Advocate Thabani Mpofu, filed an application for review of the Government’s decision alleging bias.

The medical aid giant accused the Deputy Minister of siding with Corporate 24 and turning a blind eye on CIMAS’ fraud concerns.

In the same week, the lawyers filed an urgent chamber application barring Government from cancelling CIMAS’ licence.

On Friday High Court judge Justice November Mtshiya, granted CIMAS’ application and barred Government from cancelling the licence pending determination of the dispute between the two firms.

“Pending determination of this matter, the applicant is granted the following relief:

“The decision of the first respondent (Deputy Minister Musiiwa) to cancel the applicant’s licence be and is hereby stayed,” ruled Justice Mtshiya.

In the application filed at the High Court, Deputy Minister Musiiwa was accused of being biased in handling the dispute of the two companies.

“First respondent acted in a biased manner in that he elected not to investigate applicant’s legitimate complaints against third respondent’s conduct, which led to the dispute between applicant and third respondent, but has proceeded to vigorously pursue the resolution of the third respondent’s subsequent complaint ignoring the fact that third respondent’s complaint cannot be properly resolved without addressing applicant’s complaint against the third respondent,” reads the papers.

CIMAS’ lawyers argued that the Deputy Minister’s decision was unreasonable under the circumstances.

“First respondent’s decision to cancel applicant’s licence is unreasonable in that it effectively places the applicant in a position where it must abandon good corporate governance procedures and embark on a course of action that is not economically sound and is not in the best interest of its members, especially as it would open applicant’s business to possible fraud by unscrupulous service providers,” the papers read.

The lawyers further argued that the Deputy Minister’s decision was bad at law and a breach of CIMAS’ right to administrative justice.

CIMAS argued that it was in a very sound financial position and that cancelling its licence was unlawful.

Cancellation of a medical aid licence can only be done by the permanent secretary in the Ministry of Health and Child Care and Deputy Minister Musiiwa went off side in making the decision.

The actions of the Deputy Minister, the lawyers argued, amounted to abuse of power.

It was also argued that the actions were irrational in that they were designed to coerce CIMAS to engage in conduct that would open it up to fraudulent medical aid claims.




- Herald
Tags: Cimas, licence, shut, down, ,
 0

You May Like These Videos

Comments

| Comment With Facebook Submit

There are no comments.

Big Reads

Pictures show fuel tankers offloading fuel in the bush

by Moses Zhou | 2019 August 13 07:53:37

Schoolgirl drops out after continuous 'sexual abuse' by teacher

by Staff Reporter | 2019 August 13 07:42:33

Bulawayo prostitutes dollarise

by Staff Reporter | 2018 December 01 00:43:29

DRAMA as mourners fight over deceased loan sharks' loot

by B-Metro | 2018 November 30 23:35:19

'Tsvangirai's ex' on police wanted list

by B-Metro | 2018 October 19 12:39:23

Dumped man glasses wife's face with broken beer bottle

by Staff Writer | 2018 October 19 12:32:05

Zimbabwe prostitutes hike prices

by Zimbabwe prostitutes hike prices | 2018 October 18 17:13:08

Pastor shocks female congregant with new panties

by Metro Writer | 2017 March 28 10:50:44

Harare man steals 10kg mealie meal from neighbour

by Court Reporter | 2017 March 28 07:56:29

Four company directors die in Vumba Mountain plane crash

by Staff Writer | 2017 March 28 07:38:59

Man with 'deformed' body bashes parents

by Staff Writer | 2017 March 24 09:48:46

Mugabe Knows Nothing About The Zimbabwe Constitution: MP

by Staff Reporter | 2016 October 01 08:12:02

Troubled Harare Giants Dynamos Falls Into Another Deep Crisis

by Own Correspondent | 2016 October 01 07:49:17

Shock As Local Bank Denies 'Rich' Mugabe's Son Heifty Credit

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 30 19:14:54

Mugabe "Home Coming" And "Thank You" Rally On Cards

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 23 06:48:24

Prof Moyo Was Dumped By Western Embassies, Claims Mutsvangwa

by Staff Reporter | 2016 September 22 10:08:07

Prof Jonathan Moyo In Fresh Beef With War Vets

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 22 07:48:10

You Are Too Old To Lead, Aging Zim President Mugabe Told

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 22 07:19:25

Younger Lover Beats Up Sugar Mama For Cheating

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 03:21:43

Anti-Corruption Commission Loses Property In Failed Probe

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 03:18:19

Mutsvangwa's Son Caught Up In Rape Case

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 01:24:00

REMAINING PSL FIXTURES: ONLY 7 WEEKS LEFT

by Sports Correspondent | 2016 September 20 01:21:33

Victims Involved In Horror Crash Named

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 01:16:09

Man Kills Uncle For Taking Him To Prophet

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 01:11:08

Mphoko Threatens Zimra Over Irregular Taxes

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 01:07:44

China Pours $46m On New Parliament Construction

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 01:05:11

SHOCKING:14 Year Old HIV-Positive Boy Rapes 7 Pupils

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 20 00:04:55

Tajamuka Slams Zimpapers, Fumes Over

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 19 11:56:42

Mthwakazi Activists Torment Mujuru

by News Editor | 2016 September 19 10:52:58

We Did Not Fire Live Bullets: Police

by Staff Reporter | 2016 September 19 08:09:20

Ruling On 58 Protesters Expected Today 



by Court Reporter | 2016 September 19 08:10:40

6 Zanu PF Youths Nabbed For Assaulting Cops

by Court Reporter | 2016 September 19 08:11:50

Mutare Con-artist Cracks Zanu PF

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 19 08:13:32

MSU Student Caught Peddling Drugs Tor Tuition Fees

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 19 05:29:18

ZIMRA Dishes Out Rewards To Faithful Tax Payers

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 19 05:24:19

Headmaster ‘Steals’ $17 000 From School's Fees

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 19 05:21:24

Mujuru Party Fails To Pay $15 000 For Printed T-shirts

by Own Correspondent | 2016 September 19 05:14:37